Share

Culture

SOAP BOX: Yo X Games, What’s The Score?

A confusing new format for the X Games

Soap Box is a chance for others to use the Whitelines platform to express their views, have a rant or just scream SNOWBOARDING into the eternal void of the internet. These opinions are not necessarily those of the WL editorial staff.

Written by: Harry Johnson // @harryjjourno // @hazzaj1407

That’s a wrap for X Games 2020. The results are in, but which riders championed the podiums this year? That bit we know but how well did they do? We’re left in the dark there because X Games 2020 decided to ride with a new format.

“We’re left in the dark there because X Games 2020 decided to ride with a new format”

This year the competition decided to shake things up. Instead of your standard snowboard competition with the repetitive runs and gymnastic style tricks, the biggest extreme festival in the world threw away all scoring in the freestyle comps and instead instated a leader board with a jam style format. Much like what we’ve seen in Big Air in the past, the jam format was comprised of a countdown clock that encouraged riders to lay down different tricks in the time limit.

Zoi Sadowski-Synnott | PC: PHIL ELLSWORTH / ESPN IMAGES

Sounds interesting? Well, it certainly was from an audience’s point of view. The new format made room for creativity. It allowed riders to change up runs and throw tricks that aren’t usually on their comp list. If only we knew what the judges were actually judging? Every time a new rider finished, we were left wondering if they would take the top spot. I say wondering, guessing I think is the right word to use. Next they’ll have the audience voting online for the winner.

“The new format made room for creativity. It allowed riders to change up runs and throw tricks that aren’t usually on their comp list”

Compare this to past Open events where we are told a score for every hit. Instead, we don’t know which tricks were actually taken into account and which were ignored. What’s worse is that they thought the format could work across all disciplines.

Queen Jamie | PC: Fred Lee/ Getty Images

Consistency is normally a good thing, right? We all like our gravy without those god-awful fatty lumps that clump up in the mash. But consistency isn’t always perfect. Especially when it means that the same contest rules are used across all disciplines. Everything counts. The commentators keep saying, ‘If they fall, they will still be marked on the tricks to follow’. Well, this works fine on a slopestyle course where there is still a downslope allowing riders to gain speed and hit the other jumps providing, they haven’t lost all confidence in the bail. But try doing this after falling from the 22-foot wall of the superpipe. Not many riders are going to fall and then accumulate enough speed to throw a 12 at the bottom, to better their score. Or sorry, their position on the leader board.

“Nobody could argue that Zeb Powell’s knuckle hits weren’t the gnarliest tricks to come out of the Games”

Creativity was certainly rife in Aspen this year. We saw the likes of Halldór Helgason step out and put a jersey on again and nobody could argue that Zeb Powell’s knuckle hits weren’t the gnarliest tricks to come out of the Games. Not forgetting Fridge’s knuckle on the slopestyle course. The introduction of a rail jam and superpipe session also showed the Games’ appreciation to the creative side of the sport. We saw a huge variety of different tricks and numerous amounts of NBD’s. What more could you ask for? The change is meant to stop regimented perfect runs. But when that’s what all the riders are used to, can we expect them to comply?

Zeb Powell | PHIL ELLSWORTH / ESPN IMAGES

As fun as it was to see the variety of 10s and 12s being thrown in the pipe from the riders, we still saw riders being put in the top spot when they landed full near-perfect runs. Near perfect but not perfect!

“Nobody is perfect despite what your mum tells you”

At least the new format diminishes the idea of a perfect score, that ridiculous act of giving somebody 100. I’m sorry but nobody is perfect despite what your mum tells you. Instead, we were left bemused as to what the judges were actually judging. Essentially the judges just rated the riders on overall impression. It allowed riders to be creative and improvise runs that didn’t quite go to plan because they were being judged for ‘everything’.

Snowboard comps have never been the easiest to follow so to try and understand this format is only going to make it harder. This overall impression thing, surely it eliminates the idea of a victory lap. A rider who’s had more runs is going to have a better overall impression, right? Well not in the Pipe it didn’t, although I’m not saying Scotty James didn’t deserve Gold.

Phil Ellsworth / ESPN Images

Anyway, let’s forget about it. It was a sick show at the end of the day so let’s not burden ourselves with the detail. Let’s look forward to next year and I’m sure a new format, when they eliminate scoring for good and just show a highlight reel of all the riding over the weekend and throw out some medals when it’s all over.

Newsletter Terms & Conditions

Please enter your email so we can keep you updated with news, features and the latest offers. If you are not interested you can unsubscribe at any time. We will never sell your data and you'll only get messages from us and our partners whose products and services we think you'll enjoy.

Read our full Privacy Policy as well as Terms & Conditions.

production